Chimie

Please pardon my lack of posts. I'm traveling in France for a couple of weeks and haven't had a chance to write anything. I visited l'École Nationale Supérieure today. I was able to see original research samples from Louis Pasteur. What a treat!

Odeur d'Asperge

Yes, it is asparagus season. I love this vegetable. Raw straight out of the garden, steamed with white wine and garlic, coated with olive oil and roasted on the grill, I can't get enough of it! Of course, for some of us that means plenty of malodorous urinary discharge. Yes, I'm talking about the infamous Asparagus Pee! The culprit - Asparagusic Acid. Derived from valine, this acid is unique to asparagus and appears to be the metabolic precursor to a number of odiferous sulfur-containing compounds. In its pure form, this colorless solid melts around 76 °C. For those with the enzyme to break it down (~40% of the population) the results appear in the urine usually within 15 minutes of ingestion. Interestingly, not everyone has the ability to smell the satisfying stench, thus complicating studies to determine why some have smelly piss and others do not. I am one of the lucky ones who can both produce copious quantities of metabolites such as methyl thioacrylate (among others) and delight in its pleasing perfume. For those of you deprived of this evolutionary gift, I have sympathy, as you will never truly enjoy the full experience of asparagus season. (edited 5/8/07, 5:28 pm to fix structures)

Your Road to a PhD

I'd like to call out some of the lurkers who read my blog to come forward and make some comments. I'm curious to find out what influences a student's decision for choice of graduate school in chemistry. So, if you have your PhD, are in a PhD program now, or going to join a PhD program soon, please tell me what was important for your choice of school. Was it location? Science? Stipend? What? Did family issues change your decision? Would you only look at schools on the coasts, or did you look across the middle of the country too? How influential were your undergraduate mentors? What about international studies? This would apply to those from the US going abroad as well as those from outside the US coming to America. And finally, what sources did you use to find graduate programs? Do you put any stock in the web sites that list rankings of graduate programs?

A Rhodium Thing

Ever since my first encounter with aldehyde C-H insertion by rhodium, I have been intrigued by the possibilities of the acylorganometallic intermediates. In Org. Lett. a nice formal [4+2] cycloaddition appeared utilizing ortho-vinyl benazaldehydes and olefins or alkynes. The reaction proceeds via C-H insertion to form an acylrhodium followed by a migratory insertion to produce a rhodacylopentene. This reacts with an alkene to form the product shown. Chiral ferrocenyl phosphine ligands afforded at least modest level of enationselectivity. If alkynes were utilized, napthol products were produced. Although most yields and selectivities were modest, it is an interesting transformation. It seems to be limited in scope. Without the arene ring cyclization did not take place. Instead the acylrhodium simply reacts with the olefin in a reductive Heck-type process to afford an acyclic ketone.

Ken Tanaka, Daiki Hojo, Takeaki Shoji, Yuji Hagiwara, and Masao Hirano, DOI: 10.1021/ol0704587

Cross Coupling of Anilines

A fascinating paper appeared on the JACS ASAP site this morning from Ueno, Chatani and Kakiuchi. They used a ruthenium catalyst to carry out a cross coupling of an aryl amine with a phenyl boronate. What is remarkable is the fact that the transition metal did oxidative addition to an aryl-nitrogen bond. Success of the reaction was dependent on having a chelating carbonyl group adjacent to the amine, however, this is still the first example of oxidative addition to a hitherto unreactive C-N bond.

Satoshi Ueno, Naoto Chatani, and Fumitoshi Kakiuchi, DOI: 10.1021/ja0713431

ASAP Thursday

Some good papers have shown up on ASAP this week. Here's two that rose to the top for me.

First is a contribution from Shu Kobayashi with some very interesting chemistry using chiral Calcium complexes. The reaction he investigated was the Michael addition of glycine derivatives with acrylates. He showed the importance of an enolizable proton on the bis-oxazoline ligand and suggests that the reactive species is a calcium Brønsted base. This generates a chiral calcium enolate that undergoes Michael addition to the acceptor. Subsequently, an intramolecular Mannich reaction ensues to afford pyrrolidines in very high selectivity.

Susumu Saito, Tetsu Tsubogo, and Shu Kobayahsi, JACS, DOI: 10.1021/ja0709730

Organocatalysis is all the rage now, and even we are trying our hand at some. Xiao has just reported a slightly new twist on organocatalysis by carrying out an intramolecular Friedel-Crafts reaction with indoles to form tricyclic compounds. Selectivities are are pretty good in some cases.

Chang-Feng Li, Hiu Liu, Jie Liao, Yi-Ju Cao, Xiao-Peng Liu, and Wen-Jing Xiao, OL, DOI: 10.1021/ol0703130

Beta Amino Acid Rearrangement

Here's the answer to the mechanism question I posed at the end of the last post. Some have suggested a 4-membered ring intermediate. While that cannot be ruled out, a mechanism that does not include the high strain of a bridged 4-membered ring seems more plausible.

Since this is an aminoacid, it will exist in it's zwitterionic form. Thus, the quaternary ammonium will not be acylated. The carboxylate is converted to a mixed anhydride. Then it undergoes a beta-elimination of the ammonium to open the 6-membered ring. This is followed by an acylation of the resulting amine to form the rearranged lactam.

This reaction was reported by Henry Rapoport (JACS 1970, 92, 5781). He cites an older paper by Ferles (Coll. Czech. Chem. Commun., 1964, 29, 2323.

Update: As liquidcarbon points out in the comments, the free amine of the ring-opened intermediate above would likely be acetylated in refluxing acetic anhydride. Another possible route to the product would involve an intramolecular acylation forming a bridging 4-membered ring, followed by beta elimination. Possible, but I'm not sure how well the bridgehead hydrogen sigma orbital would overlap with the sigma star orbital of the C-N bond.

Mechanism Challenge Answered

Tynchtyk, over at Chemist in a Transition State, posted a very interesting transformation and challenged us to propose a mechanism. Here is the reaction.

At first glance, this looks like some kind of reductive amination reaction. However, on closer inspection, you can see that there is one less carbon in the product than the starting material. Furthermore, there are no reducing agents present, only acid (and presumably water). Of course the obvious starting point is to react the secondary amine with the aldehyde to form a cyclic imminium structure. Once generated, this is nicely set up to undergo a [3,3]-sigmatropic rearrangement to transfer an allyl group to the imminium carbon. The resulting formaldehyde imminium product is then hydrolyzed in the presence of water to afford the product plus an equivalent of formaldehyde. The full mechanism is shown below. Notice I am a stickler for showing every proton transfer step! No shortcuts here.

Tynchtyk says this problem appeared in a science olypiad for High School Students in Moscow. I wish our high school education here in the states was up to this kind of challenge.

Thanks, Tynchtyk, nice problem! In the spirit of problem solving, let me pose a new challenge. This is one of my favorite transformations.

Feline Frolics

I have two cats and they drive me absolutely nuts. Always demanding and always getting in trouble. Today was no different. I had need of some thyme for my spice cupboard, so I snuck out at lunch and stopped by my favorite health food store that has a huge array of dried herbs and spices in bulk. I bought an ounce of thyme and some other goodies and stopped off at home to put them away. No sooner did I drop the bag on the kitchen floor and head to the 'little chemists room' did my biggest pain in the ass, Sam, discover a new toy. Yes, a small little plastic bag of thyme. By the time I got back to the kitchen, he had ripped the bag open and was squirming around on the floor in a big mess of herbs! *sigh* You'd think it was catnip or something, the way he was carrying on. Out of curiosity, I dug up information on the compound found in catnip. It turns out to be nepetalactone. Nothing I could find indicated that thyme contains this terpene. So what was Sam all worked up about? Well, the major volatile constituent of thyme is the terpene thymol. Very different structure than nepetalactone. Although thyme does not contain nepetalactone, catnip does contain significant amounds of thymol. Interestingly, thymol is also used as in ingredient to repel feral cats. Sam sure is odd.

ASAP Thursday

The first thing I do when I get into the lab in the morning is make my coffee. The second thing is to see what has appeared on the web journals. I suppose since I'm blogging that I should share with you the articles that catch my eye. Here's a couple from today.

Karl Scheidt has a very nice example of umpolung chemistry catalyzed by N-heterocyclic carbenes in a [3+3] cycloaddition. This appeared on the web yesterday.

Audrey Chan and Karl A. Scheidt, JACS DOI: 10.1021/ja0709167


Interestingly, I was just teaching my synthesis students about the utility of diazo compounds for cyclopropanation and Wolff rearrangements and what appears on OL this morning? A very nice and practical method for the preparation of diazo compounds. This could come in handy.

Muhammad I. Javed and Matthias Brewer, OL DOI: 10.1021/ol070515w